Marina del Rey condo towers are structurally sound but need repairs, engineering study says – San Bernardino Sun

Marina del Rey’s iconic high-rise condo towers are in significant need of repairs to fix deteriorating cement, exposed and corroded reinforcement bars and damaged waterproofing on rooftop decks but are otherwise structurally sound, a county-mandated engineering report concluded.

Los Angeles County officials ordered the structural engineering study last summer after residents expressed concern the 48-year-old Marina City Club faced the same fate as South Florida’s Champlain Towers South, which collapsed in June following years of unheeded reports showing the building needed urgent repairs. Ninety-eight residents and guests died in the predawn tragedy, most while asleep in their beds. 

The Marina City Club report found cracks in walls and cement, signs of water intrusion in parking garages, “spalling” and crumbling concrete and water-damaged rooftop decks. Cement fastenings to handrails along walkways and on private balconies also were deteriorated, creating a safety hazard, the report said.

It referred the problems to building operator Essex Property Trust, recommending the publicly traded apartment firm make necessary repairs to the three 16-story condo towers, parking structures and apartments. Officials from the San Mateo-based firm couldn’t be reached for comment.

The Marina City Club condominium and apartment complex in Marina del Rey is under increased structural scrutiny in the wake of the Florida condo collapse. (Image from Google Maps)

However, the report by Saiful Bouquet Structural Engineers of Pasadena found no danger of imminent collapse.

“No significant structural damage was observed,” the 14-page engineering report, released publicly Tuesday, Feb. 22, concluded. “It is our opinion that the majority of damages observed were a result of normal wear and tear of the structure and/or moisture/water intrusion in the building envelope.”

The report recommended that further engineering studies be done to determine how the condo owners and the adjacent apartment building should address the needed repairs and how they could prevent future deterioration and corrosion.

“Ultimately, it’s maintenance issues that kind of got neglected over time,” said Steven Frasher, a spokesman for the L.A. County Public Works Department.

A county statement said Essex is engaging Saiful Bouquet and other consultants to prepare repair documents and do more assessments.

County Public Works Director Mark Pestrella ordered the complex in July to have a qualified engineering firm do a structural analysis of the building. Numerous studies show the complex needed $80 million to $140 million in repairs, although its maintenance reserves were severely underfunded.

A 2021 consultant’s report said operators needed to patch roof leaks, renovate and waterproof the pool deck, install new water pipes, upgrade the electrical system, fix leaking windows and update elevators.

The iconic 16-story Marina City Club Towers overlooking the harbor at Marina del Rey on Thursday, July 8, 2021. Complaints about deferred maintenance have plagued residents for years at the posh Marina City Club, a 10-acre complex consisting of 600 condominiums in high-rise towers, a three-story, 101-unit apartment building, swimming  pools, tennis courts, boat slips, restaurants, a fitness center and offices. (Photo by Dean Musgrove, Los Angeles Daily News/SCNG)

Residents of the three, circular towers complained about leaking pipes that flooded their condos, water pooling on roofs and in parking garages, and leaking in stairwells.

The damage to the waterfront Marina condos appeared eerily similar to reports of crumbling concrete and parking garage flooding that preceded the June 24 collapse in Surfside, Fla.

Champlain Towers residents had years of studies showing their oceanfront building needed major repairs. But even though the $15 million estimate for fixing Champlain’s problems paled in comparison to the cost of repairing the Marina City Club, residents resisted special assessments to raise the needed cash.

An official investigation appears to be months, if not years, away from finding a cause of the collapse. But subsequent news reports show Champlain Towers probably had issues far exceeding those of the Marina City Club and most other buildings in the nation.

Engineers hired by the Wall Street Journal and the Miami Herald concluded that design flaws, combined with years of neglect, caused a steady erosion of the Champlain Towers infrastructure. Some columns at the base of the building were undersized and lacked reinforcement bars, while parts of the building lacked adequate shear walls to provide stability, the newspapers reported.

Nonetheless, at least one Marina City Club resident familiar with the Saiful Bouquet report remains skeptical of its conclusions, saying it didn’t probe deeply enough to determine the building is safe.

The report said its conclusions were based mainly on visual inspections, adding that it made external observations only because apartments and condos are occupied.

Sixth-floor Central Tower resident Elana Mondragon complained that one beam in a parking garage is buckling, that sections of the garage roof appear distorted and that water still is pooling in parts of the garage.

“I’m not an engineer, but I can see with my uneducated eye how these things are buckling up and are not holding the weight,” Mondragon contended. “It’s not a neutral report. It doesn’t even address structural integrity.”

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *